Join America Back to Work, a weekly podcast, video, and blog series that covers timely and relevant topics affecting the labor market and workforce with industry experts. The series includes recruiting, hiring, retention, employee satisfaction, customer service, background screenings, and more.
Are There Any Free Background Check Services?
When it comes to doing a background check for hiring or other purposes, the idea of using a free service can be appealing.
However, while some free options are available, relying on them may not be the best choice for most organizations.
Here’s why opting for a paid background check service from a reputable provider is often a smarter decision.
Limited and Outdated Data Sources
Free background check tools typically scrape information from readily available public records online, such as various government websites or publicly accessible databases.
While this might sound sufficient, there are several pitfalls to be aware of:
- Inaccuracy and Incompleteness: Most free tools are limited to publicly accessible digital records, which means they often miss key information. These records can be outdated or incomplete, leading to significant gaps in the data. For instance, some states and counties may not have digitized all their records, meaning vital information might be missing.
- Lack of Comprehensive Coverage: Paid background check services offer access to more extensive and up-to-date records. S2Verify, for example, provides access to more than 4,100 federal, state, and local government sources. This ensures a more thorough screening process that captures all relevant information, not just what’s available online.
- Risk of Inaccurate Information: An incomplete or inaccurate background check can lead to hiring risks, including legal liability, hiring unqualified candidates, or overlooking red flags that would be caught with a comprehensive background check. A robust service will provide verified and accurate data, reducing the likelihood of these issues.
Lack of Human Oversight and Compliance Risks
One of the most critical drawbacks of using free background check tools is the absence of human oversight. Many of these services promise instant results, but the data is often unverified and can be inaccurate or misleading.
This lack of human verification presents several challenges:
- No Expert Review: Free services rely solely on automated data scraping without human intervention. This means that any inaccuracies or discrepancies in the data go unchecked, potentially leading to errors. A professional service like S2Verify employs a team of experts to review and verify the data, ensuring the information is accurate and reliable.
- Compliance Threats: Background checks are subject to various federal, state, and local regulations, including the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Free background checks are more likely to produce non-compliant results without human oversight. For instance, they may include outdated or irrelevant information that could violate privacy laws. In contrast, paid services have dedicated adjudication teams that are proficient in FCRA compliance, helping businesses avoid potential legal pitfalls.
- Better Decision-Making Support: Professional background check services provide clients with vetted reports that enable more informed hiring decisions. Knowing that experts have verified the data can provide peace of mind and help reduce the risk of making a bad hire.
No Customer Support and Limited Problem Resolution
Background checks can be complicated, and issues often arise that require professional support. Free services typically offer no customer support, leaving users to navigate problems independently.
This can create several challenges:
- No Assistance for Disputes: If an applicant disputes the findings of a background check, a lack of support from a free service can result in delays and confusion. This is particularly problematic when dealing with sensitive issues such as mistaken identity or outdated information.
- Navigating Complex Regulations: Employment screening regulations are constantly evolving, and they vary from state to state and even county to county. Without guidance from experienced professionals, it can be challenging for businesses to remain compliant with all relevant laws and regulations.
- High-Quality Customer Support: Reputable paid services like S2Verify provide dedicated customer support to help employers handle any issues that arise during the background check process. Whether it’s navigating complex regulations, addressing disputes, or understanding the nuances of a report, having access to expert assistance can make a significant difference. S2Verify boasts an award-winning, US-based customer support team to ensure all clients—from large enterprises to small businesses—get the needed help.
Additional Tips for Choosing a Background Check Service
While paid background check services offer clear advantages, not all services are created equal.
Here are some tips for choosing the right provider:
- Look for Accreditation: Ensure that the background check service is accredited by the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA). This accreditation confirms that the company complies with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and adheres to industry standards for information security, compliance, client education, and data accuracy.
- Evaluate Turnaround Times: While speed is important, overly fast turnaround times can sometimes indicate a lack of thoroughness. Balance the need for quick results with the importance of accuracy and depth of information.
- Check for Comprehensive Services: Ensure the service covers various checks, including criminal records, education and employment verifications, credit reports, driving records, and more. A comprehensive service will provide a more complete picture of an applicant.
- Consider Integration with HR Systems: Integration with existing HR systems can streamline the background check process and improve efficiency for businesses with high hiring volumes.
- Read Reviews and Get Recommendations: Look for reviews and testimonials from other businesses in your industry to gauge the quality of service. Word of mouth and reputation can provide valuable insights.
Invest in Quality for Peace of Mind
While free background check services may seem attractive due to the cost, they come with significant limitations and risks. Investing in a professional background check service is the best route for businesses that want to ensure compliance, protect their reputation, and make informed hiring decisions.
Services like S2Verify provide access to extensive databases, expert oversight, and reliable customer support, offering a more comprehensive and accurate solution for your background screening needs.