Join America Back to Work, a weekly podcast, video, and blog series that covers timely and relevant topics affecting the labor market and workforce with industry experts. The series includes recruiting, hiring, retention, employee satisfaction, customer service, background screenings, and more.
How to Spot Quiet Firing In the Workplace
One of the critical roles of an HR pro is fostering a workplace environment where employees feel supported, valued, and motivated to contribute. However, trends like quiet firing are challenging this effort and threatening employee engagement and morale.
Quiet firing, a management practice that indirectly pushes employees to leave without officially terminating them, is gaining attention as a silent workplace issue.
What Is Quiet Firing?
Quiet firing occurs when a manager or organization uses passive-aggressive tactics to make an employee’s experience so uncomfortable or unfulfilling that they leave voluntarily. It’s the polar opposite of quiet quitting—where employees disengage—but it stems from a similar breakdown in communication and support.
Instead of directly addressing performance concerns or interpersonal issues, quiet firing avoids conflict by withholding opportunities, resources, or acknowledgment.
This practice can have significant implications for the targeted employee and the broader workplace culture.
Signs of Quiet Firing
Recognizing the warning signs of quiet firing is essential for early intervention. Common indicators include:
- Sudden Reduction in Responsibilities. The employee is assigned less effective or menial tasks, signaling a loss of trust or confidence.
- Exclusion from Key Projects and Meetings. Being left out of discussions or projects that align with their role or expertise.
- Lack of Feedback or Development Opportunities/ Regular performance discussions, mentoring, and upskilling stop, leaving employees stagnant.
- Subtle Social Isolation. Employees are excluded from team bonding activities or casual office interactions.
- Overly Critical or Micromanaged. The manager enforces unrealistic expectations or constantly criticizes without constructive guidance.
- Salary Stagnation and Denied Raises. Despite meeting goals, the employee’s requests for pay adjustments or promotions are ignored.
The Employer’s Role: Addressing Quiet Firing
Quiet firing often stems from poor leadership practices, unclear expectations, or unresolved conflicts. But HR can intervene when it’s apparent what is happening.
First, equip leaders with tools and training to provide constructive feedback and engage in difficult conversations. If an employee’s performance is lacking, managers must address it directly with clarity and respect.
Implement regular one-on-one meetings where employees can voice concerns, discuss career goals, and receive actionable feedback. Create a culture where communication is open and proactive.
Conduct anonymous employee surveys to assess whether employees feel valued and supported. Identifying patterns of dissatisfaction can spotlight managers prone to quiet firing behaviors.
Ensure employees can access HR or other neutral parties to address concerns safely. Encourage employees to report subtle mistreatment without fear of retaliation.
Quiet firing thrives in toxic environments. Address workplace dynamics by fostering team cohesion, recognizing individual contributions, and ensuring fair treatment across roles.
For Employees: Navigating Quiet Firing
Employees experiencing quiet firing face a difficult and disheartening situation. If an employee comes to you fearing that they or one of their colleagues is being quietly fired, you can suggest they document behaviors.
Ask them to maintain a record of instances that indicate potential quiet firings, such as missed promotions, exclusion from projects, or critical feedback without justification. They can also gain clarity by scheduling a meeting with their manager to address concerns. Coach them to express their observations constructively and ask for actionable feedback or an explanation for the changes in their role.
The HR Professional’s Perspective
Quiet firing is detrimental to both employees and organizations. For employees, it can erode confidence, diminish morale, and force an unnecessary career transition. For employers, it leads to higher turnover rates, damaged reputations, and weakened team dynamics.
HR leaders are responsible for intervening when we see quiet firing behaviors. By promoting transparency, fostering open communication, and addressing poor management practices, we can help ensure all employees feel valued and supported. This is not just about addressing quiet firing—it’s about building a workplace where everyone thrives.
By tackling the root causes of quiet firing, HR can transform the workplace into an environment that prioritizes fairness, development, and mutual respect—a win for employees and organizations.