Best Practices for Navigating Employment Law Compliance

As businesses strive to create equitable and compliant hiring practices, legislative shifts like Ban the Box, pay transparency mandates, and other employment regulations are reshaping how we hire, retain, and grow employees. 

We need practical, compliant strategies that align with today’s standards while fostering employee trust. Here’s an in-depth look at key employment law trends and best practices for staying compliant.

The Intent and Unintended Consequences of Ban the Box

Ban the Box legislation is designed to give candidates with criminal records a fair shot at employment by removing questions about criminal history from initial job applications. The goal is to reduce bias and ensure employers focus on applicants’ skills and qualifications before considering their backgrounds. However, while well-intentioned, Ban the Box laws present some unintended challenges.

As Pavithri Kilgore, the founder of KPSK Consulting, explains in this week’s America Back to Work, “Many employers, especially smaller ones, aren’t fully aware of state-specific regulations that govern what can and can’t be considered in background checks. Without guidance, businesses can inadvertently violate these laws and face costly consequences.”

To help avoid pitfalls, companies should:

• Conduct checks only after making a conditional job offer. This approach complies with Ban the Box requirements and aligns with fair hiring practices by allowing skills and qualifications to take precedence.
• Assess its relevance to the job if a background check reveals a criminal record. Consider the nature of the offense, how long ago it occurred, and its connection to the role.
• Equip managers and HR teams with training on Ban the Box laws and other state or federal compliance standards. Regular training reduces risk and keeps your hiring process compliant and fair.

Moving Toward Salary Equity with Pay Transparency

As pay transparency legislation grows, businesses must disclose salary ranges in job listings. While these laws primarily address external transparency, organizations should also consider the benefits of transparency within their teams.

External transparency helps candidates evaluate the roles they apply for and promotes fairness by ensuring consistent pay ranges. Companies in states like California and Colorado, where pay transparency laws are enforced, must disclose pay ranges with job postings.

Transparency within the organization promotes trust and allows employees to understand their roles’ growth potential. Kilgore notes, “Companies should establish and communicate salary bands for each position to ensure internal equity.” Internally, this transparency supports career development and can help retain employees.

To do so, consider the following:

• Define salary ranges for all roles and update them regularly. This will make it easier for HR to communicate expectations and help prevent pay disparities.
• Many states prohibit asking candidates about their salary history to prevent perpetuating past pay inequities. Focus on what the role is worth rather than a candidate’s previous earnings.
• Regular pay audits help ensure you remain competitive in the market, adhere to new laws, and identify pay disparities.

The Importance of Background Checks

Background checks are crucial in hiring, particularly for roles with safety or security responsibilities. While Ban the Box legislation seeks to create equitable hiring, background checks remain essential to mitigating risk. An efficient background screening process also helps prevent bad hires that could lead to decreased morale, lost productivity, or damaged brand reputation.

To ensure compliance and effectiveness, background checks should:

• Be conducted after a conditional offer, aligning with Ban the Box.
• Adhere to federal Fair Credit Reporting Act guidelines, including gaining candidate consent.
• Be accurate and timely; prolonged screening processes can lead to candidate drop-offs.

In industries requiring stringent security standards, such as healthcare or finance, the right background check provider can also offer monitoring solutions, helping maintain compliance even after hiring.

Key Employment Law Trends to Watch

As 2025 approaches, several additional trends and emerging laws are worth monitoring:

1. States are leading efforts to expand leave options, including family, parental, and bereavement leave. Companies should stay informed about changes to local leave laws and consider updating their leave policies to align with new standards.
2. The Federal Trade Commission has proposed a rule to ban non-compete agreements in many industries, a move expected to impact countless businesses. HR teams should stay updated on this ruling and consider alternatives for protecting intellectual property and trade secrets.
3. Artificial intelligence is growing in hiring, but it’s not without risks. While AI can streamline processes and reduce costs, it can also perpetuate biases if not implemented carefully. As regulatory frameworks are rapidly developing, stay ahead of AI-related legislation, particularly around transparency and anti-discrimination practices.

Kilgore shares that “AI can improve hiring practices, but employers must use it ethically, ensuring that it doesn’t lead to unintentional discrimination or privacy breaches.”

Best Practices for Compliance and Equity in Hiring

Compliance and equity in hiring are about following the law and building trust within your organization. Here are practical ways to achieve both:

1. Regular audits ensure your processes and policies align with changing laws and organizational needs. They can also help identify biases, improve the candidate experience, and highlight areas needing adjustment.
2. Clear, well-documented hiring policies, pay, and benefits build trust with candidates and current employees. Make sure these policies are accessible to all and reviewed annually.
3. Equip HR teams and hiring managers with the tools to make informed, fair decisions. This includes understanding Ban the Box, FCRA requirements, and pay transparency laws. By providing ongoing training, HR teams can confidently navigate compliance challenges.
4. Employees value transparency. Regular check-ins and an open-door policy make employees feel heard and valued. Engagement surveys and feedback sessions are also valuable for understanding how employees perceive policies and can inform future improvements.
5. A trusted background screening provider can offer guidance on staying compliant with background check laws, including Ban the Box and FCRA requirements. This partnership can make the hiring process more efficient and reduce risk.

Real-World Consequences of Non-Compliance

Failing to comply with employment laws carries severe risks, including legal action, fines, and damage to reputation. For example, ignoring Ban the Box in applicable states could lead to costly fines, while a lack of transparency in pay can contribute to employee dissatisfaction and turnover.

Kilgore emphasizes, “Having a knowledgeable advisor can protect your investment and help avoid fines and legal consequences. Many compliance issues are unintentional but can still be costly if not addressed properly.”

By proactively addressing compliance, organizations can mitigate risk and foster a positive work environment that supports current and prospective employees.

Looking Ahead: 2025 Employment Law Trends

In addition to existing changes, here are some trends HR leaders should anticipate in 2025:

• Federal adoption may follow with more states prioritizing leave policies, including bereavement and family leave. Stay updated on state-specific requirements and consider expanding your policies to stay competitive.
• As AI usage grows, so will regulatory scrutiny. Many anticipate federal standards surrounding AI in hiring, including transparency requirements and guidelines to avoid discrimination. Partner with technology providers who prioritize compliance and ethics in AI.
• With remote work here to stay, expect more guidance on compensating remote workers fairly and ensuring their work environment complies with local labor laws.
• More states are expected to adopt pay transparency laws that mandate external posting of salary ranges and internal transparency within organizations.

As employment laws evolve, staying informed and proactive is critical. By fostering a compliant, equitable workplace, organizations reduce risk and create a culture of trust that attracts and retains top talent.

SUBSCRIBE TO BLOG