Navigating Candidate Disputes: A Guide for HR Professionals

For all of the background screenings you do, every once in a while, you’ll encounter a candidate who disputes what you uncover. Understanding how to navigate these disputes is crucial for maintaining compliance and fairness and ensuring a transparent hiring process that respects candidate rights. 

Following are some effective strategies for those times when a candidate disputes their record.

Immediate Steps to Take

  • Understand the Dispute Process: Familiarize yourself with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and local laws governing employment background checks. These regulations outline specific rights for candidates, including the right to dispute inaccurate or incomplete records.
  • Notify the Candidate: Upon receiving notice of a dispute, promptly inform the candidate that their dispute has been received and is being taken seriously. Transparency about the timeline and process for investigation is key.
  • Contact the Background Screening Provider: Immediately refer the dispute to the background screening company. Reputable providers like S2Verify have clear procedures for investigating disputes and are obligated to re-verify the contested information.

During the Investigation

  • Maintain Open Communication: Keep the lines of communication open with the candidate throughout the investigation process. Providing updates and timelines helps maintain a positive relationship with the candidate, even if the outcome isn’t in their favor.
  • Document Everything: Document all communications with the candidate and the background check provider. This documentation is vital for compliance purposes and will be beneficial if the dispute escalates.
  • Prepare for Possible Outcomes: Understand the dispute’s potential outcomes, from correcting inaccuracies to confirming the initial findings. Consider how each outcome will influence the hiring decision.

Resolving the Dispute

  • Inform the Candidate of the Outcome: Once the background screening provider concludes the investigation, promptly communicate the findings to the candidate. If the dispute was resolved in their favor, reassess their candidacy in light of the corrected information.
  • Take Action Based on the Findings: If the investigation upholds the original findings, ensure that your decision-making process remains compliant with equal employment opportunity laws and is consistent with company policy on hiring standards.
  • Review Your Policies: Regularly review your background check and dispute resolution policies to ensure they align with best practices and legal requirements. Continuous improvement of these policies can reduce the frequency and impact of future disputes.

Best Practices for HR Professionals

  • Educate Your Team: Ensure that all HR team members understand how to handle background check disputes and are aware of the legal obligations involved.
  • Candidate Education: Inform candidates about the background check process at the outset, including their rights to dispute inaccuracies. This preemptive step can foster a more transparent and trusting relationship from the start.
  • Choose the Right Partner: Partner with a reputable background screening provider that not only complies with legal standards but also offers guidance and support in handling disputes.

Navigating Candidate Disputes

Navigating candidate disputes over their background check record requires a balanced approach that respects their rights while protecting the integrity of the hiring process. 

By following these guidelines, you can navigate these challenges effectively, ensuring that your hiring practices remain fair, compliant, and respectful of all candidates.


Subscribe to America Back to Work

Join America Back to Work, a weekly podcast, video, and blog series that covers timely and relevant topics affecting the labor market and workforce with industry experts. The series includes recruiting, hiring, retention, employee satisfaction, customer service, background screenings, and more.